Survey results from the ESC Council for Cardiology Practice
Did you know that your browser is out of date? To get the best experience using our website we recommend that you upgrade to a newer version. Learn more.

Survey results from the ESC Council for Cardiology Practice

Private Practice Cardiology in Europe (2012)

The ESC Council for Cardiology Practice (CCP) performed an internet-based survey on private practice cardiology in Europe in late autumn 2012.
We received 1329 answers of which, for the purposes of the survey, we excluded 191 responses from participants not working in practice, 176 responses from non-ESC member or non-Affiliate countries and 85 answers that were incomplete.

876 practicing cardiologists from 52 ESC Member or Affiliate countries completed the survey.

Country participation

As seen in Table 1 the country with the highest participation rate was Italy (114 participants). Russia, Greece, Spain and Ukraine were also among the top 5 countries.

It is of interest to note that many eastern European countries without representation in our Council* were among the most active in the survey:  Russia, Ukraine, Romania, Poland and Bulgaria.

The mean age of responders was 48 and 28 % of them were female.  The percentage of female cardiologists varies much between countries with more female cardiologists in practice in Eastern Europe (see Table 1).

* We would like to remind our readers that is easy for a country to become a member of CCP. Please contact councils@escardio.org for information.

Percentage of working time spent in practice

The practicing cardiologists represent  a group with wide experience:  61% of participants had more than 10 years of practice after having received their cardiology certification. 

The proportion of work done in the cardiology practice and in hospitals varies:  38% reported that they worked at least 90% of their time in office practice whereas 31 % spent less than 50% of their working time in their practice.

This also differs between countries (as shown in Table & Graph 2) depending on differences in the organization of specialized health care. In some countries most cardiologists work part time in their office and part time in non-academic or in university hospitals whereas in many countries this combination is more uncommon or regulatorily forbidden.

Patients average age and main disease category

The participating cardiologists were requested to characterize the patients who consulted on the day of the survey by age and by main disease category.

  • The mean age of patients seen that day was 57 years
  • 53% were male
  • 28 % were aged 70 and above.

As shown in Table & Graph 3 the five most frequent symptom/disease groups were evaluation of chest pain, hypertension,  known coronary artery disease and atrial fibrillation.

Diagnostic procedures

A total of 534 cardiologists also gave information about the diagnostic procedures performed on the survey day.

As shown in Table & Graph 4 the vast majority performs standard out-patients procedures like ECG, Exercise ECG, Transthoracic Echo, Holter ECG and ambulatory BP monitoring. 

More specialized procedures like Stress ECHO, Cardiopulmonary Exercise testing, Tilt Table Testing and Body Box testing were done by a significant proportion.

This shows that the practicing cardiologists in many countries perform advanced procedures often thought of as belonging to hospital based cardiology.

New echocardiographic techniques

Newer echocardiographic techniques are also being adopted by practicing cardiologists:

  • Use of TDI to obtain E/e’ was reported by 2/3 of the participants
  • 2-D speckle strain was used by one in four participants
  • 3-D echo was used by one in five participants

ESC Congresses

Continued medical education is of prime importance and we also asked whether they had attended the last ESC congresses. Of the 867 cardiologists 35% had attended either ESC Congress 2011 or ESC Congress 2012.

The cost of congress, travel and accommodation was:

  • sponsored totally by industry for 50% of the participants
  • sponsored partly by industry for 12%
  • paid on their own budget for 34%
  • funded by their employer/hospital for 4%. 

Conclusion

This survey has brought important information regarding European cardiologists working in out-of hospital offices.  In a future “borderless” Europe also regarding cardiology practice, such information is crucial to describe similarities and differences between the ESC countries regarding cardiology office practice.

The ESC Council of Cardiology Practice will continue to develop targeted surveys to describe the working conditions and the work done by practicing cardiologists. 


Table 1. Number of answers to the survey by country

 

Italy

Answers114
Female23%
 

Georgia

Answers 9
Female22%

 

Russia

Answers85
Female55%
 

Sweden

Answers 9
Female33%

 

Greece

Answers 65
Female15%
 

Armenia

Answers 8
Female50%

 

Spain

Answers 51
Female12%
 

Latvia

Answers 8
Female75%

 

Ukraine

Answers 40
Female53%
 

Switzerland

Answers 8
Female13%

 

Romania

Answers 39
Female62%
 

Slovakia

Answers 7
Female14%

 

Poland

Answers 35
Female29%
 

Finland

Answers 6
Female17%

 

Germany

Answers 33
Female9%
 

Kosovo

Answers 5
Female0

 

Belgium

Answers 30
Female13%
 

Macedonia,F.Y.R

Answers 5
Female20%

 

Portugal

Answers 29
Female34%
 

Slovenia

Answers 5
Female40%

 

France

Answers 28
Female11%
 

Albania

Answers 4
Female67%

 

Bulgaria

Answers 23
Female39%
 

Azerbaijan

Answers 4
Female5%

 

Egypt

Answers 22
Female23%
 

Belarus

Answers 4
Female50%

 

Austria

Answers 19
Female10%
 

Kazakhstan

Answers 4
Female25%

 

Czech Rep.

Answers 16
Female25%
 

Iceland

Answers 3
Female0

 

Turkey

Answers 15
Female7%
 

Ireland

Answers 3
Female0

 

Netherlands

Answers 14
Female14%
 

Lebanon

Answers 3
Female0

 

Norway

Answers 14
Female0
 

Syria

Answers 3
Female0

 

Serbia

Answers 14
Female43%
 

Estonia

Answers 2
Female100%

 

Hungary

Answers 13
Female8%
 

Libya

Answers 2
Female0

 

United Kingdom

Answers 13
Female15%
 

Algeria

Answers1
Female0

 

Bosnia and Herzegovina

Answers 12
Female17%
 

Denmark

Answers1
Female0

 

Israel

Answers 12
Female17%
 

Luxembourg

Answers1
Female0

 

Lithuania

Answers 12
Female75%
 

Moldova

Answers1
Female0

 

Cyprus

Answers 11
Female18%
 

Morocco

Answers1
Female0

 

 
Answers 
Female 
  Total answers
Answers 876
Female 

 

Answers Female   Answers Female

Italy

114 23%

Georgia

 9 22%

Russia

85 55%

Sweden

 9 33%

Greece

 65 15%

Armenia

 8 50%

Spain

 51 12%

Latvia

 8 75%

Ukraine

 40 53%

Switzerland

 8 13%

Romania

 39 62%

Slovakia

 7 14%

Poland

 35 29%

Finland

 6 17%

Germany

 33 9%

Kosovo

 5 0

Belgium

 30 13%

Macedonia,F.Y.R

 5 20%

Portugal

 29 34%

Slovenia

 5 40%

France

 28 11%

Albania

 4 67%

Bulgaria

 23 39%

Azerbaijan

 4 5%

Egypt

 22 23%

Belarus

 4 50%

Austria

 19 10%

Kazakhstan

 4 25%

Czech Rep.

 16 25%

Iceland

 3 0

Turkey

 15 7%

Ireland

 3 0

Netherlands

 14 14%

Lebanon

 3 0

Norway

 14 0

Syria

 3 0

Serbia

 14 43%

Estonia

 2 100%

Hungary

 13 8%

Libya

 2 0

United Kingdom

 13 15%

Algeria

1 0

Bosnia and Herzegovina

 12 17%

Denmark

1 0

Israel

 12 17%

Luxembourg

1 0

Lithuania

 12 75%

Moldova

1 0

Cyprus

 11 18%

Morocco

1 0
       Total answers  876  



Table 2. Percentage of working time spent in practice

 Norway
% time spent

95%

 Hungary
% time spent

68%

 Austria
% time spent

59%

 Netherlands
% time spent

90%

 Bulgaria
% time spent

66%

 Spain
% time spent

58%

 Germany
% time spent

85%

 Ukraine
% time spent

65%

 Israel
% time spent

54%

 France
% time spent

79%

 Romania
% time spent

64%

 Lithuania
% time spent

47%

 Czech Rep.
% time spent

77%

 Italy
% time spent

63%

 Poland
% time spent

35%

 Greece
% time spent

70%

 Egypt
% time spent

60%

  
% time spent     
 Russia 
% time spent

69%

 Portugal
% time spent

59%

  
% time spent 
  % time spent   % time spent   % time spent
Norway

95%

Hungary

68%

Austria

59%

Netherlands

90%

Bulgaria

66%

Spain

58%

Germany

85%

Ukraine

65%

Israel

54%

France

79%

Romania

64%

Lithuania

47%

Czech Rep.

77%

Italy

63%

Poland

35%

Greece

70%

Egypt

60%

       
Russia 

69%

Portugal

59%

   


Graph Working time spent in practice

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 3. Main symptom/disease groups for patients seen on the day of survey

 Chest pain evaluation
Number of patients

1548

 

14,3%

 Evaluation for hypertension
Number of patients

1523

 

14,0%

 Known CAD, evaluation
Number of patients

1303

 

12,0%

 Atrial Fibrillation
Number of patients

 992

 

9,1%

 Palpitation (not AF) 
Number of patients

 820

 

7,6%

 Control of known heart failure 
Number of patients

 735

 

6,8%

 Asymptomatic CAD risk evaluation 
Number of patients

 673

 

6,2%

 Evaluation of dyspnoea, shortness of breath  
Number of patients

 606

 

5,6%

 Control of known valvular heart disease 
Number of patients

 557

 

5,1%

 Murmur evaluation 
Number of patients

 430

 

4,0% 

 INR control
Number of patients

 323

 

3,0%

 Cardiomyopathies 
Number of patients

320

 

3,0%

 Pacemaker evaluation 
Number of patients

 286

 

2,6%

 Syncope 
Number of patients

 257

 

2,4%

 Other
Number of patients

 249

 

2,3%

 Peripheral Artery Disease 
Number of patients

 146

 

1,3%

 Pericardial disease
Number of patients

  76

 

0,7%

 

 Total number of patients

Number of patients

 10844

  
  Number of patients  
Chest pain evaluation

1548

14,3%

Evaluation for hypertension

1523

14,0%

Known CAD, evaluation

1303

12,0%

Atrial Fibrillation

 992

9,1%

Palpitation (not AF) 

 820

7,6%

Control of known heart failure 

 735

6,8%

Asymptomatic CAD risk evaluation 

 673

6,2%

Evaluation of dyspnoea, shortness of breath  

 606

5,6%

Control of known valvular heart disease 

 557

5,1%

Murmur evaluation 

 430

4,0% 

INR control

 323

3,0%

Cardiomyopathies 

320

3,0%

Pacemaker evaluation 

 286

2,6%

Syncope 

 257

2,4%

Other

 249

2,3%

Peripheral Artery Disease 

 146

1,3%

Pericardial disease

  76

0,7%

 Total number of patients

 10844

 


 

Graph Symptoms on survey day

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 4. Procedures performed by the participating cardiologists (534 answers)

 ECG
Performed regularly

97%

Performed on day of survey

93%

 Transthoracic Echo
Performed regularly

91%

Performed on day of survey

76%

 Holter ECG
Performed regularly

88%

Performed on day of survey

55%

 Exercise ECG
Performed regularly

86%

Performed on day of survey

52%

 Ambulatory BP monitoring
Performed regularly

83%

Performed on day of survey

43%

 Trans Oesophageal Echo
Performed regularly

52%

Performed on day of survey

13%

 Stress Echo Physical 
Performed regularly

51%

Performed on day of survey

18%

 Dobutamine Stress Echo 
Performed regularly

47%

Performed on day of survey

9%

 Spirometry
Performed regularly

40%

Performed on day of survey

16%

 Tilt Table Testing
Performed regularly

34%

Performed on day of survey

7%

 Cardiopulmonary Excercise testing (CPX) 
Performed regularly

29%

Performed on day of survey

8%

 Sleep apnea analysis 
Performed regularly

28%

Performed on day of survey

7%

 Body Box Testing 
Performed regularly

21%

Performed on day of survey

6%

  Performed regularly Performed on day of survey
ECG

97%

93%

Transthoracic Echo

91%

76%

Holter ECG

88%

55%

Exercise ECG

86%

52%

Ambulatory BP monitoring

83%

43%

Trans Oesophageal Echo

52%

13%

Stress Echo Physical 

51%

18%

Dobutamine Stress Echo 

47%

9%

Spirometry

40%

16%

Tilt Table Testing

34%

7%

Cardiopulmonary Excercise testing (CPX) 

29%

8%

Sleep apnea analysis 

28%

7%

Body Box Testing 

21%

6%

Graph Procedures performed


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Council for Cardiology Practice thanks everyone who participated in this survey